The Four Things the Best Nashville Medical Malpractice Lawyer Has to Prove in Tennessee
Think about a woman named Carol who had a knee replacement and developed an infection. She's furious. The surgeon says infections happen in a small percentage of these procedures no matter what. He's right about that. He might also be wrong about whether this one should have happened. Both can be true, and figuring out which applies to Carol is the entire job.
Cummings Law's Franklin page lays out the four elements a Tennessee malpractice claim must prove. I want to go through each one the way the Best Nashville medical malpractice lawyer would, using Carol's knee, because the four element test is the thing that separates "I'm upset" from "I have a case."
Element One: A Provider Patient Relationship
Easy for Carol. The surgeon operated on her. There's a consent form, a chart, a bill. This element trips up only unusual situations, like a doctor who answered a question at a dinner party. For hospital stays, surgeries, ER visits, it's almost always satisfied.
Still, it has to be pled and proven. Which providers had a relationship with you matters when you're deciding whom to send the 60 day presuit notice to. Miss one and you can lose the claim against that person.
Who Else Might Be in the Relationship
Nurses. The anesthesiologist. The hospital itself. The site's Franklin page says the standard of care covers everyone from surgeons and nurses to the hospitals themselves, so the relationship element can apply to several defendants at once.
Element Two: Breach of the Standard of Care
This is the heart of it. The standard of care, loosely, is what a competent provider in the same field would have done. The Cummings "what is medical malpractice" page describes it as the level of treatment a competent professional in the same field would deliver under similar conditions. Carol's infection by itself doesn't prove breach. A skipped antibiotic protocol, a contaminated instrument, ignoring early signs of infection at the follow up visit, those would.
Tennessee Code 29 26 115 requires expert testimony to establish breach. An orthopedic surgeon has to review Carol's chart and say, in writing, whether the care fell short.
Known Risks Aren't Breaches
The site's Franklin page is clear: some procedures carry known risks even when performed correctly. Infection after joint replacement is a known risk. The question is whether this infection resulted from a deviation. That's a fact question an expert answers, not a feeling.
Where the Breach Often Hides
In the follow up. Carol's wound looked red at her two week visit, she mentioned fever, and the note says "doing well." That gap between what she reported and what was done is where breach lives in a lot of infection cases.
Element Three: Causation
The breach has to have directly caused the injury. Say the expert finds the surgeon did skip a step. The defense will argue Carol would've gotten the infection anyway because of her diabetes. Causation is where cases get won and lost on expert credibility.
The Cummings homepage describes expert witnesses explaining complex details to a jury, and causation is the most complex detail of all. Your expert has to connect the skipped step to the infection in a way twelve regular people can follow.
Causation Is Also Expert Territory
Same statute. Both breach and causation must come through expert testimony. The written expert opinion, which the site's claims process page describes, covers both.
Element Four: Damages
Carol needs real losses. Medical bills for the revision surgery, lost wages from the months she couldn't work, pain and suffering. The site lists these across its pages and adds that severe cases may support punitive damages. Tennessee doesn't cap economic damages, which for Carol means the full cost of her second surgery and her lost income is recoverable.
A Best Nashville medical malpractice lawyer starts documenting damages on day one, because by the time liability is established the bills should already be organized and the lost wage figure should already be calculated.
The Procedure Around the Four Elements
Even with all four, Tennessee makes you send a 60 day presuit notice and file a certificate of good faith. The deadline is one year from injury or discovery with a three year hard stop. The elements get you a case. The procedure keeps it alive.
What Carol Did
She called Cummings Law for a free consultation. The firm took her records, sent them to an orthopedic expert, and that expert's opinion decided whether she had a claim. Brian Cummings is board certified in medical malpractice, has 25+ years of litigation experience, and works on contingency, so the review cost her nothing. The office at 4235 Hillsboro Pike is open 24/7 at (615) 241 2000.
Conclusion
Relationship, breach, causation, damages. That's the test. Carol's anger was understandable, but it wasn't evidence. The expert opinion was. If you're sitting with a bad outcome and wondering whether it was negligence, the Best Nashville medical malpractice lawyer can walk your facts through all four elements and tell you honestly where you stand.
FAQs
Is an infection after surgery malpractice? Not by itself. It must result from a breach of the standard of care, confirmed by an expert.
Who proves breach and causation? A qualified medical expert, as required by Tennessee Code 29 26 115.
Can I sue the hospital as well as the surgeon? Potentially. The standard of care applies to hospitals too, per the Cummings site.
Does the Best Nashville medical malpractice lawyer evaluate all four elements for free? Cummings Law offers a free consultation and handles cases on contingency.
- Art
- Causes
- Crafts
- Dance
- Drinks
- Film
- Fitness
- Food
- Games
- Gardening
- Health
- Home
- Literature
- Music
- Networking
- Other
- Party
- Religion
- Shopping
- Sports
- Theater
- Wellness