Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Compliance in Florida: What Physician Practices, Clinics, and Hospitals Need to Know
A medical director agreement signed years ago. A lease with a referring physician that was never updated. A marketing company paid per patient. None of these feels like a violation when it's signed, but each can create liability under federal and Florida law, sometimes years later and sometimes without anyone intending to break a rule.
Florida providers face overlapping fraud-and-abuse laws, and a single arrangement can violate several at once. This guide covers the laws that matter, the arrangements that most often cause trouble, and how to build a compliance program that holds up under audit.
Have an arrangement you're unsure about? Contact our healthcare attorneys for a complimentary consultation, or call (561) 455-7700.
Quick Summary
- Stark Law is a strict-liability civil statute. Intent doesn't matter, only whether the arrangement fits an exception.
- The Anti-Kickback Statute is a criminal, intent-based law covering anyone who pays or receives remuneration for federal program referrals.
- Florida law goes further, with statutes that apply to all payors, including commercial insurance.
- Most violations arise from ordinary arrangements: leases, directorships, compensation plans, and marketing contracts.
- Review before you sign. Fixing an arrangement beforehand costs far less than remediating it after an investigation.
The Laws Florida Providers Must Navigate
Federal Stark Law (Physician Self-Referral Law)
The Stark Law (42 U.S.C. § 1395nn) prohibits a physician from referring Medicare patients for "designated health services" to an entity with which the physician or an immediate family member has a financial relationship, unless an exception applies. Designated health services include clinical laboratory, physical therapy, radiology and imaging, durable medical equipment, home health, and inpatient and outpatient hospital services.
Stark is strict liability. If an arrangement misses even one element of an exception, the resulting claims can be non-payable, and repayment obligations can reach back years. Our regulatory compliance practice helps providers structure arrangements to meet these exceptions.
Federal Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS)
The AKS (42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7b(b)) makes it a felony to knowingly and willfully offer, pay, solicit, or receive anything of value to induce or reward referrals of items or services payable by federal healthcare programs. It reaches any referral source, not just physicians, and carries potential prison time, fines, civil monetary penalties, and program exclusion.
Compliance usually depends on fitting within a statutory exception or regulatory safe harbor. An arrangement outside a safe harbor isn't automatically illegal, but it needs careful facts-and-circumstances analysis.
Florida-Specific Laws
| Law | What it does |
|---|---|
| Florida Patient Self-Referral Act of 1992 (§ 456.053, Fla. Stat.) | Florida's analogue to Stark, covering a broader range of payors |
| Florida Anti-Kickback Statute (§ 456.054, Fla. Stat.) | Prohibits kickbacks for referrals by licensed healthcare providers |
| Florida Patient Brokering Act (§ 817.505, Fla. Stat.) | Criminal statute barring payments to induce patient referrals, with no federal-program requirement |
| Florida Health Care Clinic Act (Part X, Ch. 400, Fla. Stat.) | Requires many clinics to be licensed by AHCA, with ownership and medical director requirements |
An arrangement that is safe under federal law may still be risky under Florida law, particularly when commercial payors are involved.
Where Florida Practices Most Often Get Into Trouble
1. Medical director and consulting agreements. Payments that aren't fair market value, aren't documented, or compensate services never performed are among the most common enforcement triggers.
2. Space and equipment leases. Leases with referral sources need a signed writing, fair market rent, a term of at least one year, and no rent that varies with referral volume or value.
3. Physician compensation models. Productivity bonuses, profit shares, and in-office ancillary services arrangements must be structured carefully to stay within Stark exceptions.
4. Marketing and referral relationships. Paying marketers or "patient recruiters" per patient or by percentage is a well-known risk under the Patient Brokering Act and the AKS.
5. Joint ventures and ASC ownership. Physician-owned surgery centers, imaging centers, and labs need structuring that satisfies safe harbors and state licensing rules. See our work on healthcare business transactions and laboratory compliance.
6. Unlicensed or improperly structured clinics. Operating without AHCA licensure or a valid exemption can make claims uncollectible. Read our guide to the Florida Health Care Clinic Act: licensing and exemptions.
7. Management service organization (MSO) structures. Lawmakers and regulators are paying closer attention to ownership and control arrangements. See our analysis: Congress just fired a warning shot at healthcare MSOs.
Not sure whether one of your arrangements is exposed?
Our attorneys review compensation models, leases, and referral relationships for Florida practices, clinics, and hospitals.
Call (561) 455-7700 or Request a consultation →
What's at Stake: Penalties and Exposure
- Repayment of claims plus civil monetary penalties
- False Claims Act liability, including treble damages and per-claim penalties (see DOJ's tightening of False Claims Act enforcement)
- Criminal prosecution under the AKS or Florida statutes
- Exclusion from Medicare, Medicaid, and other federal programs
- Licensing discipline from the Florida Department of Health or AHCA
- Qui tam whistleblower suits, frequently filed by current or former employees or competitors
Because whistleblowers can file under seal, a practice may not know it is under investigation until a subpoena or civil investigative demand arrives.
How to Build a Defensible Compliance Program
- Inventory every financial relationship with referral sources: leases, directorships, bonuses, loans, and free or discounted services.
- Put every arrangement in writing, signed before services begin, and make sure the paper matches actual practice.
- Document fair market value for compensation and rent with independent support.
- Review compensation formulas for any link to referrals.
- Confirm commercial reasonableness: would the arrangement make sense even if no referrals flowed?
- Train leadership and staff on fraud-and-abuse basics and reporting channels.
- Audit and monitor on a recurring schedule, with a contract tracking system so nothing expires or goes stale.
- Act on red flags quickly. The CMS Self-Referral Disclosure Protocol and the OIG Self-Disclosure Protocol may allow resolution on better terms than waiting to be investigated.
When to Call a Healthcare Attorney
Bring in counsel before you:
- Sign or renew a medical director, lease, or referral-adjacent agreement
- Add a new physician, partner, or investor
- Open a clinic, ASC, or ancillary service line
- Launch a marketing or referral arrangement
- Receive a subpoena, CID, audit request, or payor or AHCA inquiry
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Stark Law the same as the Anti-Kickback Statute?
No. Stark is a civil, strict-liability law limited to physician referrals of designated health services. The AKS is a criminal, intent-based law covering any referral source for federal program business.
Does Florida law apply if we only bill commercial insurance?
Often, yes. The Florida Patient Self-Referral Act and the Patient Brokering Act are not limited to government payors.
Can we fix a non-compliant arrangement ourselves?
Sometimes, but changing documents without legal guidance can create new problems or affect disclosure options. Speak with an attorney first.
What should we do if we receive a subpoena or CID?
Preserve all records, don't alter or delete anything, and contact counsel immediately.
Talk to a Florida Healthcare Regulatory Attorney
Florida Healthcare Law Firm represents physicians, medical groups, hospitals, clinics, pharmacies, and laboratories on regulatory compliance, licensing, and transactions. We offer a complimentary consultation to see whether we can help.
Call (561) 455-7700 | Toll free (888) 455-7702 | Contact us →
- Art
- Causes
- Crafts
- Dance
- Drinks
- Film
- Fitness
- Food
- Games
- Gardening
- Health
- Home
- Literature
- Music
- Networking
- Other
- Party
- Religion
- Shopping
- Sports
- Theater
- Wellness